Search results

@criver The main mistake would be assuming, the word you hate so much, that the MC is being dishonest with himself. We have no other reason to believe that other than your conclussions. It's never pointed out in the story nor at any point he acts contrary to what he thinks (at least, there is...

@criver Quoting: Morality and lawfullness are different things. You are obligated to learn the law, that's why crime in ignorance is still crime (you could say you commited the crime of not learning the law). But morality judges only the intention of an action, not it's result. The MC is...

@criver Let's simplify then. I will be stating my points, your counterpoints and my explanations of them. We have drifted into the realm of refferences and exact numbers and those don't help. 1: We can consider the MC to be morally good or at least not evil by pretty much any standart. Your...

@criver Children cruelty doesn't affect the current point, so we'll supress the issue. I don't have a paper at hand, but there are some that hold more or less the same weight as yours. Well, yeah he can. Or maybe he cannot because he purchsed a mule or a gladiator as a sex slave while he is a...

True and non discutable. Partially false. They are selfish, but not inherently cruel. Integrity or not, we are talking about weeks of chasing that slave around the house in the worst case scenario. And beating her up while trying to to get too hurt by her in the best. Just because she looked a...

@criver For the same reason you would not use a good knife as a screwdriver. This only actually applies in the extreme cases. If a slave states that she does not want to be used for sexual pleassure, the ideal master will not, a good master may but will prefer not to, an average master is more...

@criver I see no correlation. I'll explain it again. If a slave openly states she is against being used as a sex slave, then using her as sex slave will be seen akin to punishment or abuse to her. Case 1: the master is not rich enough to purchase another slave for sexual use, so he intends to...

TL;DR: In a society where slavery is common, owning a slave =/= being a dickhead. @criver And there is where your viewpoint is plain incorrect. You can go back to Roman and Greek records about this exact issue. In the civilized world of 2018 we consider the mere idea of slavery as immoral and...

@criver Yes I am rationalizing. If I things don't make sense after rationalizing them it's a sign of bad writting. About the preference of a buyer, again we come down to assuming that most peoples are not douchebags. Even if you wish to buy a slave, you still woud prefer to cause the least...

@criver We are mostly saying the same thing but we are not understanding each other because words are hard. I'm just pointing out the difference between licensing and copyright. You can't and won't get in trouble for just distributing unlicensed but copyrighted material. There is no actual way...

@criver Yes and no. Yes by capacity: the master CAN do it. No by will: the master will be more willing not to do it as per explained above: if they can afford a dedicated sex slave, they will prefer to do so; if they can't, they may still chose not to rape their regular slave in order to not...

By the way, I got so engrossed in all of this that forgot what it was all about. TL;DR: it doesn't actually matter whether you can or cannot get sued in this context. You are mostly right. Yet the law can be twisted into escaping. @criver I won't be looking for the explanation now, and you are...

Stop all this sniping BS. There is no contract or license for a work to be done by a single group. There is only the effort you are putting in doing something that will eventually do someone else. If you see the effort as worthwhile, there should be nothing to stop you.

@mruggeri2 We have seen it a couple of times. I think this fight will be like those. 2 panels and she is out cold. Ginther should be incapable of a long fight, he is not suited for that.

Wall of text again. I sure don't know how to write a readable comment. @criver I might be wrong, but I kinda remember the slaver mentioning her agreeing. I'm too lazy right now to confirm it and it doesn't matter all that much, you might be right. About the motivation ... I think I assumed it...

@Khaos The chapter is not reportable. The attitude may be wrong, but in the end the person did what they were supposed to do: they uploaded a valid chapter translated and edited. The quality may be crap and the translation may be off, but the work remains done. @criver I'm not an expert...

@criver You can't get sued for overdistributing copyrigted material. You can get sued for distributing any amount of licensed material. A copyright essentially prevents anyone from claiming your work to belong to them. The license is the right of profit. I lead a manga / anime asociation here in...

@criver I can't argue about the MC right now. You may be 100% right, in which case most of what I said would be BS and the series would plummet to the depth of the author's self satisfaction. I will keep hope I'm right since it leads to a more intresting development on the long run. And about...

@criver Kamachi Kazuma is, indeed, a genius. Yet he is writing LN. Also this guy is too bold for his own good, like when they fired the guy who made the Haruhi Suzumiya anime script (he had very good ideas, but they were so good they went overboard). The sole idea of portraying a MC who intends...

@criver And about what you said about female slaves voluntarily becoming sex slaves, and the advantages of that ... Well, I will point out that our author here is really good. I'm damn serious, this guy is almost a genius in world and character building. Look at this this way: It's not that...