Search results

  1. M

    Chi no Wadachi - Vol. 10 Ch. 84 - Yell

    @JosMenLed you seem to assume that it's right as Seiichi came out of the house. Why? He woke up a 3:25am, and "4 in the morning" could be more than one hour after that. How long did Seiichi stay outside, eyes closed, taking in the snow? We don't know if it was 15mn or 1h. Also it's not like...
  2. M

    Goblin Is Very Strong

    @jimkage source? Mangaupdates still say ongoing.
  3. M

    Overlord - Vol. 13 Ch. 53.2

    Lol at all the guys getting so agitated about on commenter giving their opinion on something which was not alluded to so explicitly before. The guy said his piece without bashing anyone who enjoys the manga yet so many felt offended that one would dare dislike their favorite piece of art. Or...
  4. M

    Mairunovich

    Hey it's really good for a shoujo. The MC is really flawed relatable because her thought process is always well depicted. Unlile ma'y other shoujo, you don't have to cringe your way through certain scenes, the characters act realistically and the drama does not rely on cheap misunderstandings...
  5. M

    Imperial Edict

    Tried to read this because of the positive comments but I didn't enjoy this at all. The jokes from the very first chapter to the end fell flat, and felt as stiff as the art which was aesthetically pleaseant but really bad at showing emotions. The story is not interesting either... Nothing to save.
  6. M

    Koharu no Hibi

    This was revolting. At some point I kept skipping pages to find the inflection point when the MC would snap from her sick behaviour and come to his sense. At the beginning you try to excuse him because of hormones and inexperience, but then it becomes a Stockholm syndrome story where no one...
  7. M

    Peach Milk Crown

    This is really good. A really grounded take on high school romance, with nuanced characters. It seems like many other readers expected a fluff manga, which it is not. It's not a NTR manga either. It's a manga about love, strength of character and personal growth for a group of teens. I've...
  8. M

    Koi Kaze

    I started this because it was so highly rated... But it feels like most of the people hailing it as a masterpiece seems to do so because of the rarity of a taboo topic treated somewhat maturely in manga. Maybe I would have had the same fascination if I was 12 and discovering "mature" mangas...
  9. M

    Marika-chan to Yasashii Koi no Dorei - Vol. 2 Ch. 5

    I was quite appalled by the comments until @Kekitus. I have a bit more faith in humanity now. Teenage hormones explaining an attraction to a 12 y.o girl? It's OK because he didn't act on it? He's not a pedo because he also like her as an adult? Letting her see him masturbating makes sense to...
  10. M

    The Clueless Transfer Student Is Assertive. - Vol. 3 Ch. 38

    Here is a recipe for the ramen eggs mentioned in the chapter. Easy to do, and could be your first step toward marinated/pickled food (tsukemono) https://www.justonecookbook.com/ramen-egg/
  11. M

    Red Colored Elegy

    Was this uploaded here then removed?
  12. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    @Plykiya I understand your point, but following your reasoning if the only way to find a new series to translate would be to go through an unordered list of a thousand titles, it would be fine because "finding new series isn't hard, look, a thousand titles in front of you!". What's missing from...
  13. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    @Halo Trolling I think the question is less "would some people abuse the system?" (because people will, and they do, when you look at joke descriptions, joke tagging, troll uploads or hate rating), but rather "would trolls defeat the point of the system?". For #1, one way of reducing...
  14. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    @MavB_Ver my bad I should have added more details. Generally a feature request is rarely implemented as is. You first define the goal, the outline of what it would look like, then when it's validated you dig into the details of the implementation. I expected answers to be "it could work, but...
  15. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    @Halo well at this point you're just criticising a potential implementation of the idea that would be harmful. I gave examples that would obviously need to be discussed/fleshed our further before implementing the feature. For #2 It's easy to put a line of text saying that sharing the...
  16. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    Thanks for the response @Holo, I agree with your and the others' feedback that it's actually not a good idea. What do you think of #1 and #2?
  17. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    I had typed a lot but lost my comment. To summarise my response: the criticism on the 3rd point, which is shared across your @schlo @Halo and @justforthelulz's comments, is fair. It's the weakest proposition that may lead to the most unintended consequences. To respond to the rest of @Halo's...
  18. M

    Improving reader ←→ tl groups communication :rejected:

    3 suggestions to improve information for tl groups about readers and for readers about tl groups (or individuals). 1. A way to signal interest in a manga for would-be translators. For readers if would be a "I'd like this to be translated" button, maybe with additional info like "because it...
  19. M

    MangaDex Suggested Features: Megathread

    Haven't seen this is in the list of planned features, but many have probably thought about it: a way to signal interest in a manga for would be translators. For readers if would be a specific "I'd like this to be translated", maybe with additional info like "because it was dropped/because the...
Back
Top