Search results

Been waiting for this one, thanks again for the release.

It’s actually the other way around @viliml , insistence that we shouldn’t think about the content and can’t criticise the arc and story is what is causing discourse and undercutting what should be discussion about the logic and implementation of ideas outlined and content of the chapter in the...

I should have been more clear on my examples, 5.1s strange powers and abilities fall into the category of unexplainable powers narratively. Because they are just that far beyond the reasonable narrative scope characters would be able to understand, as were Gunhas abilities and Toumas dragons...

Good job OHandS Sounds about right, I’ve felt railgun always skimmed the details to quickly get its moments over and done with; with daihaseis final battle; literally every element at play was in that nebulous realm of unexplainable power and it’s seemingly at its worst with jailbreaker where...

@ilikepi31415 I’m still part of the community so I hear what’s going on through osmosis. I hear the arc officially ended here and wanted to see people’s impressions. I’m not picking any low hanging fruit but instead criticising the attitude of the fans and giving my experience with the series...

Yeah this happens, railgun arcs usually feel disappointing at the end, unless you are binging or reading the arc all at once then it’s just an average arc that comes and goes. I can see general opinion turning around, but not the criticisms of this arc as time passes; But I don’t care, I...

I like that this thread somehow becomes about shitting on Index to detract from how shit this arc is. To railguns credit, it has to make a single arc justify 3 years of serialisation while index can have 9+ arcs of varying quality across those same 3 years. Which is hard to do, and more often...

I’ll be honest I completely forgot about this Pope segment. It’s enjoyable revisiting these old arcs in such detail and with great presentation.

The legend has returned.

Season 3 content starts from chapter 123.

Doing redraws for the other team and I noticed a weird change, what's with your redrawer drawing Tits that were censored in the raws? I mean, this doesn't seem very standard; as edits like these are usually posted on rule 34, not...

@EsperAnon much appreciated.

It's cool that you guys did a colour page, but can we have the non coloured version included in the chapter as well? It was present in a previous version of this chapter so I imagine you updated it with the colour page later.

Pretty much, this Manga is still one of the few adaptions to cover everything from the LN Accelerator vs Touma fight in the sisters arc. Looking at this chapter the fight drew a lot of inspiration from Index IIIs version and I'm glad we got that bit of respect there, from Accelerator being...

Well in the anime you can see her running away when accel attacks, one of the fewer new things I liked is kakine additional monologue about underline being used to monitor kakine and send accelerator to the scene quickly, albeit with the liaison or a middle man between him and aleister informing...

What's with Accelerator throwing money at everyone in this arc? Pretty safe chapter, not much going on and it's not too different from the anime. I'm expecting not much to be different short of less CG and maybe better character art, I'm of the opinion that the fight in Index iii was one of...

Absolutely incredible chapter, how on earth does chuuya keep doing it! Shame it'll be a while before we see Hamazura again, but this moment was more than worth the wait and I hope similar moments in the future are also worth it.

I really did like that after 15 volumes of Touma magic and science mishaps kamachi decided to try using a entirely new set of characters, structure, ideas and tone. Not many writers are bold enough to just go that far out of the established formula/comfort zone and make it work but given all...

These following chapters have to be some of my favourite moments from Index, the story structure is completely different and the new cast of characters who can and are killed off pretty casually makes each of these encounters have incredibly high stakes. Chuuya has spent more time with this...

Brilliant chapter, was pretty sure Chuuya would properly cover this melancholy calm before the storm section and I don't know how I would have reacted if it was skipped again. Will need to keep a more open mind. Hanzou is so good for Hamazuras character as the tether to his old life and...