Saving 80,000 Gold Coins in the Different World for My Old Age - Vol. 2 Ch. 17 - Beckoning Beatrice
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2018
- Messages
- 649
While the author seems to know a lot about survival stuff and some modern weaponry, he/she clearly knows jack shit about european medieval weaponry.
Swords were sidearms most of the time(but not always, it mostly depending on the nature of the battle and on what the enemy was(including if the enemy was using armor)).
Spears, pole-arms, maces and axes were primary weapons.
Great-swords weren't a thing like this. They weren't worn on the back, but rather carried by hand (and put on the shoulder to ease the weight, though they never were as heavy as fantasy great-swords). They also didn't have large blades. The blade was long and as thin as normal length swords. the blade being large gives no benefit whatsoever, instead it only brings problems in handling the weapon. Plus, steel blades won't break just like that. It doesn't need to be larger.
Bows weren't a woman's weapon. It actually takes a LOT of strength to use a bow. More so than what is needed for a great-sword. (similarly, using a rapier requires more strength than a normal sword due to how it is used and due to the techniques for it)
Edit: Also, I just realized that none of them has a shield, which is another big minus. And they wear "leather armor", which actually never existed historically. At least give them a frikkin gambeson(aka an actual very good yet cheap type of armor that was used a LOT throughout all of the Middle Ages)!
Swords were sidearms most of the time(but not always, it mostly depending on the nature of the battle and on what the enemy was(including if the enemy was using armor)).
Spears, pole-arms, maces and axes were primary weapons.
Great-swords weren't a thing like this. They weren't worn on the back, but rather carried by hand (and put on the shoulder to ease the weight, though they never were as heavy as fantasy great-swords). They also didn't have large blades. The blade was long and as thin as normal length swords. the blade being large gives no benefit whatsoever, instead it only brings problems in handling the weapon. Plus, steel blades won't break just like that. It doesn't need to be larger.
Bows weren't a woman's weapon. It actually takes a LOT of strength to use a bow. More so than what is needed for a great-sword. (similarly, using a rapier requires more strength than a normal sword due to how it is used and due to the techniques for it)
Edit: Also, I just realized that none of them has a shield, which is another big minus. And they wear "leather armor", which actually never existed historically. At least give them a frikkin gambeson(aka an actual very good yet cheap type of armor that was used a LOT throughout all of the Middle Ages)!
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2018
- Messages
- 1,013
@Sancturil
There's actually plenty wrong with this series, way before the issue of those "adventurer's" weapons.
[ul]
[*]Using a folding knife mid-combat, when she only had one hand to use. The blade's hard enough to extract one-handed when you're not being swung around by a gigantic wolf biting down on your arm.
[*]Her requiring grenade and RPG training for "self defense" in a medieval setting.
[*]Printing blueprints without even knowing the other world's measurement system (do they use meters? Inches? Goombas and Koopas?)
[*]Where did she get the necessary fonts anyway? Judging by her shop's signboard, the other world is clearly not using any alphabet used in our world. Is she a font designer?
[*]Getting simple carpenters to install electrical equipment. Where did they learn how to properly and safely handle it anyway? Did she teach them?
[*]Installing "various gaming consoles" in the other world, when she could just teleport back home to play them...
[*]People accepting her plastic-wrapped gifts without so much as a "WTF kind of material is this?"
[*]Nobody seems to be surprised at the fancy packaging in the first place, with all the extremely precise and detailed print.
[*]Selling flashlights in a world where electricity is unknown. Do these people even know what those things do, or why they'd want to buy one? And what about batteries?
[*]People using shopping baskets, as if it were a common concept in a world without supermarkets.
[*]Using a laptop, projector, microphone, and (invisible) speakers, when a simple painted (printed) canvas would've been much less likely to be questioned.
[*]Lending a freaking smartphone to take pictures. It's like she doesn't even care anymore that people could consider her a dangerous witch who needs to be eliminated.
[*]And after the initial surprise, nobody's asking about all that weird outlandish voodoo. As if the "foreign cuisine" is somehow more impressive than employing the services of a mage.
[*]Not to mention people seem more interested in buying fresh fish than finding out how she's shipping it in massive quantities. As if they couldn't ship it themselves and use the knowledge for more than just raw fish.
[/ul]
If you're still expecting realism, you might be reading the wrong manga.
There's actually plenty wrong with this series, way before the issue of those "adventurer's" weapons.
[ul]
[*]Using a folding knife mid-combat, when she only had one hand to use. The blade's hard enough to extract one-handed when you're not being swung around by a gigantic wolf biting down on your arm.
[*]Her requiring grenade and RPG training for "self defense" in a medieval setting.
[*]Printing blueprints without even knowing the other world's measurement system (do they use meters? Inches? Goombas and Koopas?)
[*]Where did she get the necessary fonts anyway? Judging by her shop's signboard, the other world is clearly not using any alphabet used in our world. Is she a font designer?
[*]Getting simple carpenters to install electrical equipment. Where did they learn how to properly and safely handle it anyway? Did she teach them?
[*]Installing "various gaming consoles" in the other world, when she could just teleport back home to play them...
[*]People accepting her plastic-wrapped gifts without so much as a "WTF kind of material is this?"
[*]Nobody seems to be surprised at the fancy packaging in the first place, with all the extremely precise and detailed print.
[*]Selling flashlights in a world where electricity is unknown. Do these people even know what those things do, or why they'd want to buy one? And what about batteries?
[*]People using shopping baskets, as if it were a common concept in a world without supermarkets.
[*]Using a laptop, projector, microphone, and (invisible) speakers, when a simple painted (printed) canvas would've been much less likely to be questioned.
[*]Lending a freaking smartphone to take pictures. It's like she doesn't even care anymore that people could consider her a dangerous witch who needs to be eliminated.
[*]And after the initial surprise, nobody's asking about all that weird outlandish voodoo. As if the "foreign cuisine" is somehow more impressive than employing the services of a mage.
[*]Not to mention people seem more interested in buying fresh fish than finding out how she's shipping it in massive quantities. As if they couldn't ship it themselves and use the knowledge for more than just raw fish.
[/ul]
If you're still expecting realism, you might be reading the wrong manga.
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2018
- Messages
- 649
@Nolonar That's fair. I indeed wasn't expecting realism in the first place. It's just that the premise used in the story (of her acting upon supposed real knowledge from her brother) combined with the medieval weapons and equipment kind of triggered one of my pet peeves that I usually don't bother commenting about.
I'm just a bit tired of how wrong medieval weaponry and settings are depicted in fiction most of the time.
I'm just a bit tired of how wrong medieval weaponry and settings are depicted in fiction most of the time.
- Joined
- Jun 23, 2018
- Messages
- 282
of course she will remember lol
it won't be funny otherwise
FEAR St. Elmo's Fire
it won't be funny otherwise
FEAR St. Elmo's Fire
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 1,176
@Sancturil Dude, they are in a town, you are gonna keep your main weapon sheathed, and out of the way, not in ready to draw position. That great sword is fine on the guy's back, unless he plans to use it in a hurry, and that's without taking into consideration an open weapon mount, like the hook that holds Kratos' axe.
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2018
- Messages
- 489
The girl in the middle is cute.
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2018
- Messages
- 624
@Sancturil oho a shad fan? 
but there is 1 thing with leather armor you forget^^ its a fantasy world ! the chances of there being monsters with steel like hide is HUGE which makes a good leather armor VASTLY superior to full plate ! if it exists that is^^ i agree with the rest
but there is 1 thing with leather armor you forget^^ its a fantasy world ! the chances of there being monsters with steel like hide is HUGE which makes a good leather armor VASTLY superior to full plate ! if it exists that is^^ i agree with the rest
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2018
- Messages
- 3,064
Casually approach child
I thought its a multiple day trip to the city? and they just dragged her with them? yike
I thought its a multiple day trip to the city? and they just dragged her with them? yike
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2018
- Messages
- 4,641
melting down gold is pretty easy and even purifying it further is something any average joe can do. It'd be real easy if the majority of impurity was mercury and lead. If it is silver or platinum then that takes more work, though platinum would make the gold worth more in large quantities
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2020
- Messages
- 274
the dude's looking like fucking waluigi
Similar threads
