a page turn animation :rejected:

[Noobmaster69__]

a page turn animation would look cool
(but far too much work for something most people won't notice)

 

[BzzBzz]

Cool doesn't equal useful.

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

Kid, I swear. It was funny at first, but you can't keep cluttering the Suggestions forum with your 'ideas'.

 

[magnetsmangadex]

I'm already wondering where to turn that feature off if it does show up. Your best bet is to find a site that has that, and read all of Moby Dick on there

I think the best way to explain it is that With real pages you have control over how fast the animation sequence takes. Animate that on a web site, and now you've got an animation that just happens.

 

[BraveDude8]

Why tho.

 

[Noobmaster69__]

@bigtiddyoneesan i thought suggestion page is for you to share your supposed IDEAs
i didn't know this page is for you to share memes.SORRY for suggesting features i would like .
honestly doI have to ask you or any other d*ckhead before i post anything.
btw thank you @magnetsmangadex now i know why it is a bad idea.
and bigtiddyoneesan if you are not gonna expain why is it a bad idea before you show your collection of memes kindly go intercourse yourself

 

[EOTFOFYL]

He has a point considering that I can see your post splattered all over page 1 as if someone went full auto.

And I'll be blunt, this is a horrible idea, its going to eat system resources for no gain. If I want to see some fracking pages turn I can walk to my bookshelf and grab a book, my ram and cpu could be better spent elsewhere. Mangadex is minimalistic and clean compared to other sites, let's keep it that way.

Your ideas are unique at best or downright rejected already. God forbid if you forget to read the sticky for the third time.

 

[sterven]

Damn you know if you get EOTFOFYL to break character it's fucking bad.

 

[Noobmaster69__]

@EOTFOFYL if the ideas are bad you are welcome to point it out
but what i post is my choice
I'm sorry but i thought this suggestion page is open for all user not some selected few know-it-all people
i wondered why there was not a lot of post compared to the number of user now i know everytime they post what they think as good ideas some know-it-all comes to diss on them
I'm sorry i didn't read the sticky for my earlier post but i read the sticky for this post
i posted this because i liked it and thought there might be people that like it.I didn't know there will be veteran people here to stop it
and i like my ideas and i will share them here
if people have some "constructive" criticism they are welcome to reply
if they are just going to be like this "do whatever you want"
btw @EOTFOFYL i know this is a bad idea to implement thanks to @magnetsmangadex but thanks anyway

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

@Noobmaster69__
If this thread was devoid of any context from the previous three days, then a mod would just dab on it with a :Rejected: and that'd be it.

However, the real point in question here is your apparent tendency to pump out suggestion after suggestion in such a short time frame, all of which I'd (generously) give a 3/10 for articulation and a 2/10 for effort.

Previous threads:

Spoiler

https://mangadex.org/thread/382168
https://mangadex.org/thread/382169
https://mangadex.org/thread/382177
https://mangadex.org/thread/382178
https://mangadex.org/thread/382233
https://mangadex.org/thread/382239

Maybe a mediocre analogy could help you process your situation better. This is like watching a toddler running too fast in absent-minded excitement, tripping over a tree root, and then unintelligibly cussing out the tree in a fit of rage.

Count yourself lucky if the next 'brainchild' of yours posted here doesn't land you a ban from creating threads. Thanks for unintentionally spicing up the forums for a bit though.

 

[EOTFOFYL]

i wondered why there was not a lot of post compared to the number of user now i know everytime they post what they think as good ideas some know-it-all comes to diss on them

Or maybe the sticky covered a lot of ideas already and most of the users are content enough to not make a post? Users are great finding problems, not so much in fixing them.

If you believe your idea was genuinely good you can start by listing merits besides something like "it's cool" or "would be awesome". Answer the "Why?" I love how you completely skimmed over BzzBzz who's comment pretty much hit the mark without the need for a wall of text.

Having ideas to share is great and all but add some meat on the bone at least.

 

[Ivegotnolife]

Perhaps it would be best to run the ideas by the users in the general discussion board before rattling the staff member's cages in the suggestion board. We can give a bit less harsh/serious feedback and advise on them there. The suggestion panel should be kept open for well considered, new and pre-vetted ideas.

This is the 'no fun zone!'

 

[MavB_Ver]

I somewhat agree with OP. They are free to share their ideas, just that they should put a little more thought and effort into their posts.

 

[justforthelulz]

OP, you might think some of the responses here are rather harsh and/or condescending,
but I have literally never seen so many REJECTED/Locked threads by the same user in such a short period of time,
indicating that even the MangaDex Staff wants you to be less impulsive with your "suggestions".