Gokushufudou: The Way of the House Husband (Fan Colored) - Vol. 1 Ch. 1 - (fan-coloured)
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
"Coloring book" is a fairly accurate description imo. Most of the backgrounds aren't even colored in. The skin has no variation in color, even painted dolls have blush on them to avoid looking completely fake. The flat coloring legitimately distracts from the excellent art, this shouldn't be uploaded here.
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2018
- Messages
- 326
I feel like this is violating the rules, specifically "Duplicate releases are not allowed" and "if you are not part of the scanlation group, do not alter the release you are uploading by any means". The scans itself are clearly those of S.A.D., but they were colored in and the credit page was changed. If these colorings were done with specific permission from S.A.D. it should be credited as such. If not - well, this would be all kinds of bad.
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2018
- Messages
- 271
I really don't think this should be here.
It borderline infringes rules 2.32 or 2.3.3, and I'd argue 2.3.5 and 1.1 too.
It's not mentioned explicitly in the rules, but given there is no new translation or editing effort, and deliberate tampering with the art of the manga, I'd say it should be taken down.
It borderline infringes rules 2.32 or 2.3.3, and I'd argue 2.3.5 and 1.1 too.
It's not mentioned explicitly in the rules, but given there is no new translation or editing effort, and deliberate tampering with the art of the manga, I'd say it should be taken down.
- Joined
- May 10, 2018
- Messages
- 624
@abdellbobo
keep it up, a fucking manga scan website doesnt need any elitism
keep it up, a fucking manga scan website doesnt need any elitism
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2018
- Messages
- 326
@morooster amazing how "not being allowed to break the rules" is reinterpreted as "elitism". Guess we should just remove the rules entirely, what purpose do they even serve. /s
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2018
- Messages
- 94
It violates upload guideline 3.2.3 too.
There's no rule prohibiting it YET, but I don't feel that fan edits like this one that go beyond simply translating text and cleaning up scanned images regardless of quality, should be allowed here in the first place.
There's no rule prohibiting it YET, but I don't feel that fan edits like this one that go beyond simply translating text and cleaning up scanned images regardless of quality, should be allowed here in the first place.
Retard_
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2018
- Messages
- 301
"2.3.2 Using the translated script of a release by another scanlation group is generally allowed as long as there is a significant difference from the source release, such as being translated to another language, or having significantly improved typesetting or higher quality raws."
@emmypacer "as long as there is a significant difference from the source release"
@AkiTooru
@SuppeBargeld
@donyadon
@SuppeBargeld
@emmypacer "as long as there is a significant difference from the source release"
@AkiTooru
@SuppeBargeld
@donyadon
@SuppeBargeld
Tunga
Group Leader
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2018
- Messages
- 6
@abdellbobo I feel sorry about all this hate you are suffering. I hope you don't regret of continuing your work because of some comments. Sure, you did apply a multiply layer, but that's how professional painting works too. You just need to train more to add shadows, highlights, (dodge tool is good for that) and try to improve the colors by using the colors which the author used in his pages.
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2018
- Messages
- 271
@Filipe
"2.3.2 Using the translated script of a release by another scanlation group is generally allowed as long as there is a significant difference from the source release, such as being translated to another language, or having significantly improved typesetting or higher quality raws."
It's not using the script from S.A.D, it's using the released chapter itself, with fanart on top of it. (And without permission too, from the looks of it)
There's no new translation, typesetting, editing or higher quality raws. Only fanart. And this is not a place for fanart.
"3.2.3 Otherwise, if you are not part of the scanlation group, do not alter the release you are uploading by any means such as removing, editing, or adding pages."
"2.3.2 Using the translated script of a release by another scanlation group is generally allowed as long as there is a significant difference from the source release, such as being translated to another language, or having significantly improved typesetting or higher quality raws."
It's not using the script from S.A.D, it's using the released chapter itself, with fanart on top of it. (And without permission too, from the looks of it)
There's no new translation, typesetting, editing or higher quality raws. Only fanart. And this is not a place for fanart.
"3.2.3 Otherwise, if you are not part of the scanlation group, do not alter the release you are uploading by any means such as removing, editing, or adding pages."
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2018
- Messages
- 271
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2018
- Messages
- 271
"The original scanlator is okay with it.
The mangadex mods are okay with it."
Source please.
"Most people are okay with it"
Have you even read half the comments on these chapters?
"I'm okay with it.
The person that painted it is okay with it."
Why would I care?
I just stated my opinion on this, I don't think fan-colourings should be on this site. It's a perversion of the original artwork and, at least previously, was misleading people about its nature (with "coloring" instead of "fan-colouring"). But I'm fine with whatever the mods eventually decide, as long as it's well regulated.
You started defending this gray-area release out of nowhere, waving around omissions on the rules as if they legitimized this. I could ask you the same, who are you arguing for and against? @Filipe
The mangadex mods are okay with it."
Source please.
"Most people are okay with it"
Have you even read half the comments on these chapters?
"I'm okay with it.
The person that painted it is okay with it."
Why would I care?
I just stated my opinion on this, I don't think fan-colourings should be on this site. It's a perversion of the original artwork and, at least previously, was misleading people about its nature (with "coloring" instead of "fan-colouring"). But I'm fine with whatever the mods eventually decide, as long as it's well regulated.
You started defending this gray-area release out of nowhere, waving around omissions on the rules as if they legitimized this. I could ask you the same, who are you arguing for and against? @Filipe
Retard_
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2018
- Messages
- 301
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2018
- Messages
- 271
@Filipe
I didn't pretend anything, I asked for a source for your quotes.
I'm also basing myself on the current rules, which is about the most official information at the moment. They don't adress this directly, and could very well be interpreted as not allowing this kind of content on the site.
And these thousands of people who read the chapter include people that clicked on it thinking it was a new chapter, only to find out this, and people who were decieved by the title and thought this was an official color version, and people who just didn't bother to complain. You can't just assume things about people just because they didn't say anything.
I'm gonna end my participation on this discussion here, as all you've done is nitpicking and using the "people are ok with it" argument. Not one compelling argument as to why fanart should be allowed in the site.
I didn't pretend anything, I asked for a source for your quotes.
I'm also basing myself on the current rules, which is about the most official information at the moment. They don't adress this directly, and could very well be interpreted as not allowing this kind of content on the site.
And these thousands of people who read the chapter include people that clicked on it thinking it was a new chapter, only to find out this, and people who were decieved by the title and thought this was an official color version, and people who just didn't bother to complain. You can't just assume things about people just because they didn't say anything.
I'm gonna end my participation on this discussion here, as all you've done is nitpicking and using the "people are ok with it" argument. Not one compelling argument as to why fanart should be allowed in the site.
Similar threads
