Hoshizora no Karasu

[MangaDex]

 

[sedition]

According to mangaupdates, this manga has like 10 chapters already translated, I tried going to the tumblr page of the translation group and got auto directed to a virus page. Could anyone try to get the rest of the chapters?

 

[Potkeny]

@sedition Unless I found the wrong site ( http://papermoonwosagashite.tumblr.com/tagged/hoshizora-no%20karasu/chrono ), chapter 4-11 are in pdf format (and saved in dropbox)? I didn't get redirected, but I have adblock and script-block, so...

Edit: Träumerei Scans said they will release 4-11, thank you!

 

[sedition]

@Potkeny thank you for looking further into this, I'm looking forward to reading more.

 

[Purplelibraryguy]

This is quite interesting so far. Oh, sure, as manga about people playing board games go it's no 3-gatsu no Lion, but then that one is a work of staggering genius by the ludicrously talented Umino Chica so it's not really a fair comparison. This is nicely done; I like the girl, and it gives you a good illusion of getting what's going on in the game.

 

[Prominis]

I can't stop comparing this to Hikaru no Go. I'm sure the manga is actually fine but...

Damn.

 

[saenahonce]

Reminds me of chihayafuru

 

[ichypa]

Wait, its already over?

 

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

Can't help but this reminds me of March Comes in Like a Lion. Is this as good as that?

 

[Purplelibraryguy]

@DANDAN_THE_DANDAN No. But that's a reallllly high bar; it's pretty good.

 

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

Holy crap my last comment was five months ago

 

[veuvecolonelmachin]

@Purplelibraryguy I really have no idea how good the shogi is in 3-gatsu, but as a go player, this one seems a bit weird at times. Not crazy "I'm gonna steal third base and score a touchdown on the wicket" level of bullshit, but more like the author has a decent grasp on go (probably better than mine, tbh, I'm just a random 1 kyu) but forces symbolism way too hard, for example the whole "I'm gonna capture everything" vs. "no stone left behind". I mean, both tendencies exist, especially in young amateurs, and the author does justice to the individuality and expressiveness that go can have, but I never felt like 3-gatsu had to clobber you over the head with in-game metaphors to get the characters across.

With that in mind, though, as you said not everyone can be Umino Chica and this is still pretty good. And, I mean, I'm still reading crap like "Reincarnated at lvl1 as an omniscient loli garbage compactor", so it can only be a step up.

 

[Purplelibraryguy]

@veuvecolonelmachin Oo, omniscient loli garbage compactor, haven't seen that one yet--sounds better than average for the genre, I should hunt it up!

(Side note: Man, the emoji on Mangadex suck so bad I like the typed version better)

 

[Zael]

Always worth it to come to the comments.

 

[petra]

This mangaka really has the exact same art style as her sister

 

[xlhca]

i liked hikaru no go better

 

[Nunally]

@DANDAN_THE_DANDAN as a random person that just casually scroll the comment section, I tell you its 2 years now

 

[mizufumaira]

thank you for picking this up! cant wait to see all the chara's development