Matchmaking of the Amagami Household (Oneshot) - Oneshot

[Chaosbreak]

The inferior version of Temple with a less likable male lead.

 

[Lunaion]

I feel like its a one-shot because we know how the entire plot will go already.

 

[tofutokwa]

Agreed

 

[Sabster]

Meh worse version of temple

 

[BestGril]

Hmmm not convinced. When I saw Negi Suggested it, i was like ... oh boy here we go again. We all pretty much know how a certain series ended...

Tbh the premise is alright, it def scream 5 toubun considering it was his assistant that did It, Yuna Being the worst offender because she literally has itsukis personality written all the way down to her face. Only thing missing is +2 girls.

The Studious MC is pretty Generic at this point nun wrong with it but it's practically the same as 5toubun.

Would've been better if it was about Shrine maidens purifying evil

gib it a 2/5

 

[hiimquanganh]

Why does the author have to make the winner pretty obvious in a oneshot?

 

[PianoConspiracy]

Dear god the tropes are strong with this one.

Shrine maidens
3 Sisters
Loli, ditz, tsundere combo
Childhood engagement
Nosebleed protagonist
Secretly kind protagonist
Strangely competent protagonist
Studying to get into something
Parents are dead/missing
Introduction via changing room
MIA adult
Supernatural? Or maybe not.

This is the same formula as so many things that its got to have something special to stand out. This at the moment has jack shit in terms of original ideas.

 

[helpmeplsnow]

This is too similar to 5toubon so when it will probably get serialized the author should change it like way more

 

[Abdibsz]

Judging by the first chapter, shrine-itsuki is the likely winner. Then again, the author is negi’s assistant, so it might not mean anything.

 

[cgr]

@hiimquanganh
@FStubbs
@Kimzark
@bouken
5toubun (by negi haruba) spoiler:
the bride

Spoiler

is not

the main girl in the oneshot

 

[Arcverson]

Ok so here is what's not gonna happen: the MC won't be choosing best girl aka onee-san aka big boobs to save his fucking life. Now you know what's not gonna happen.

 

[jean-chuck]

Nisekoi
Author: cultured
Assistant: not

Gotoubun
Author: not cultured
Assistant: maybe the cultured one

 

[hiimquanganh]

@cgr
I’m talking about the youngest sister. Just check page 14, is that an obvious winning flag for her?

 

[cgr]

@jean-chuck
komi naoshi has more than one assistant. which assistant do you mean?
If you mean tsutui taishi, what's your criteria for cultured? because I thought everyone agreed sensei's butt is culture.

@hiimquanganh
oh, that's what you meant...hmm, let's pray at a shrine for this to be serialized so we can find out if you're right.

 

[Kimzark]

@cgr ive read 5toubun and i hated the ending. also this is not negi writting, but one of his assistants... if it was that dude i would not even start it. 5toubun traumatized me with that author.

 

[FStubbs]

@cgr this isn't being done by Negi Haruba though. That would be like arguing we can use Rurouni Kenshin as a basis for figuring out how One Piece will end because Oda was an assistant on Rurouni Kenshin and they're both action shonen series.

 

[cgr]

@Kimzark
I'm saying end girl based only on oneshot, isn't guaranteed as you think
I don't care what you think about the manga/ending overall.

@FStubbs
that comparison makes no sense because those two series are completely different: with completely different goals, this and toubun (especially the oneshot) seems much more similar, with the same end goal - choose one of the sisters.

 

[FStubbs]

@cgr this series has a different "goal" as well. 5toubun was part mystery - trying to use the clues to figure out who the bride was. This isn't a mystery.

 

[Kimzark]

@crg :shrug: just because of that let me say it again, 5toubun ending was shit. Also just because you gave me a single example of a manga that ended like that doesnt mean thats not what happens 99.9% of the times. Also dont bother to reply since i wont read :)

 

[cgr]

@FStubbs

5toubun was part mystery

happened after the oneshot/first chapter. so nothing says this manga can't become part mystery later.

the toubun mystery is literally about the sister MC will choose so it's a really minor difference (technicality) compared to this oneshot.

@Kimzark

Also dont bother to reply since i wont read :)

on the 0.1% :) chance you change your mind, I'll say this:

It’s obvious you 'won't read' a lot of things, like this word

...the author of 5Toubun no Hanayome, who recommends this work

So this manga is clearly not guaranteed to be among the 99.9% that you exaggerated - I can name other non-obvious single girl endings like

Spoiler

the world god only knows

ichigo 100%