SHY
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2018
- Messages
- 306
The art (expressions, small details) is very good, but the story is way too weak and slice-of-lifey for what it is.
Also, way too many yuri undertones.
Kinda reminds me A LOT of Card Captors Sakura, just with more characters and a bit more feeling.
I will wait for it to either end or get to 100 before reading again, feels like a drag to follow on release schedule.
Also, way too many yuri undertones.
Kinda reminds me A LOT of Card Captors Sakura, just with more characters and a bit more feeling.
I will wait for it to either end or get to 100 before reading again, feels like a drag to follow on release schedule.
- Joined
- Nov 23, 2019
- Messages
- 1,094
I like this more than BnHA.
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2019
- Messages
- 165
They cant be coloring the girls like that, it'll cause a crime
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2019
- Messages
- 42
You know... they kinda gay tho...
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2019
- Messages
- 638
@LewdDewd You just answered your own question, I've noticed a trend on mangadex, this is because of the demographic of the userbase. Most series that are targeted towards a female audience are grossly overrated (yes that also includes shounen that has a very large female audience). Not to mention that certain sets of themes and tags are disproportionately either loved or outright despised. Furthermore, people are far less critical of manhua and manhwa in comparison to manga --most manhua being the pinnacle of trash yet still manage to pull a 7-8 rating when even the trashiest of 5-6 star rated manga are still miles above it.
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2020
- Messages
- 363
Reason for score this high is probably because it's been simultaneously released on dynasty cesspool, and people there have strong sense of loyalistic tribalism about them. Protecc our gurls, punch up, all that good stuff.
Not that it's bad, but upvoting to oblivion (the amount of 9s and 10s...) is I suspect being mostly done by readers who usually get their rocks and eggs off on "no males" and "girls interacting with each other" scenarios. There are lot of way better shounens out there in which general direction that crowd wouldn't had even spited, if they were aware of those titles existencein the first place that is.
7 maybe, at best 7 point something.
Not that it's bad, but upvoting to oblivion (the amount of 9s and 10s...) is I suspect being mostly done by readers who usually get their rocks and eggs off on "no males" and "girls interacting with each other" scenarios. There are lot of way better shounens out there in which general direction that crowd wouldn't had even spited, if they were aware of those titles existencein the first place that is.
7 maybe, at best 7 point something.
Small little things really irk me, and that includes the characters being cliche and hella boring, how the villain’s goal is complete nonsense, and how do they all understand each other, are they all speaking English, Japanese, RuSsIAn? (This could be a mistake on my part as I skipped through a lot of the dialogue because of how lengthy it was)
I also wished the author did a lot more research on other countries too and maybe incorporate they history into the nation’s characters. Instead of... Using their stereotypes or anime tropes as their entire personality, oh, and slap a sad backstory on them for good measure too. Additionally, having more nation heroes who are more diverse would’ve been nice to see too. Like the different national heroes in Africa, SEA, South America, etc. But instead all we get is Eurocentric nations with Japan and China... Wow, the diversity.
And the FL, Shy? I know it’s apart of her character but god damn is she so irritably shy. She literally has no confidence in herself, I guess some Japanese girls are like this because being shy is all cute and cultural aspects combined with society but... damn.
Pure of heart and the power of friendship also gets you everywhere in this manga apparently. It’s to the point that I think I could’ve slapped the main character sticker on any other character and give them plot armor and they’re good to go.
(+How come trouble happens at just the right time? It’s such a forced way to advance the plot haha)
The story seems to drag on too, the word bubbles are way to filled with information I just couldn’t even give a damn about. The art is fantastic through, but it isn’t outstandingly amazing. It’s like, generically non-generic anime art if you understand what I mean. Like a lot art I see on Twitter
And I’m surprised by the rating too, an 8.44? For this? jfc, I gave it a 4 at most, maybe a 4.5 but mate... Unless this kind of stuff is your guilty pleasure or you’re into cute anime girls fight and friendship. Then you do you.
I also wished the author did a lot more research on other countries too and maybe incorporate they history into the nation’s characters. Instead of... Using their stereotypes or anime tropes as their entire personality, oh, and slap a sad backstory on them for good measure too. Additionally, having more nation heroes who are more diverse would’ve been nice to see too. Like the different national heroes in Africa, SEA, South America, etc. But instead all we get is Eurocentric nations with Japan and China... Wow, the diversity.
And the FL, Shy? I know it’s apart of her character but god damn is she so irritably shy. She literally has no confidence in herself, I guess some Japanese girls are like this because being shy is all cute and cultural aspects combined with society but... damn.
Pure of heart and the power of friendship also gets you everywhere in this manga apparently. It’s to the point that I think I could’ve slapped the main character sticker on any other character and give them plot armor and they’re good to go.
(+How come trouble happens at just the right time? It’s such a forced way to advance the plot haha)
The story seems to drag on too, the word bubbles are way to filled with information I just couldn’t even give a damn about. The art is fantastic through, but it isn’t outstandingly amazing. It’s like, generically non-generic anime art if you understand what I mean. Like a lot art I see on Twitter
And I’m surprised by the rating too, an 8.44? For this? jfc, I gave it a 4 at most, maybe a 4.5 but mate... Unless this kind of stuff is your guilty pleasure or you’re into cute anime girls fight and friendship. Then you do you.
COF
Group Leader
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 205
Can't for the love of me understand why someone would support the cancellation of a series that's clearly beloved by a majority of readers when all it takes is not to read it. In addition it won't get axed any time soon considering it's selling on par with some of its magazines established titles with 3 volumes and seeing plenty of marketing.
Similar threads
