Siscon Ani to Brocon Imouto ga Shoujiki ni Nattara

[tedy2004]

@Kamikira00 you don't seem to realize that we talk with different religions. I am a christian, no shame but for your religion what might it be? atheism or science, thats your opinion. Since the first comment i said about this novel was only my opinion, and you are not gonna change that not because you argumented about my opinion with your opinion but just because i think your opinion is bad while you think my opinion is bad too, so lets just end it here.

P.S Love isn't everything in this world.

 

[KamiKira00]

@tedy2004 Sorry for confusion but my first comment wasn't reply to yours or anything. I just made an independend statement there.
Second, I am not religious.
Third, when we can deduce what is right and wrong independend of opinion, we can easily claim that something is good or bad objectively. Same, just happened with incest in modern age with careful people.

 

[tedy2004]

@Darkwolfix, truly your opinion is related to science, I agree with your opinion on that. But to me, my opinion is different (like everyone else, if they, of course, they make one for themselves ) since it is related to my religion, and yea if that's to your liking then that's your decision. I suppose I've sounded too mean since I got angry at the other guy with his "convincing" arguments. I know this is an excuse but I still say it since its a part of the truth why I made arguments like that to you and him to say my personal opinion in the argument. Well, goodbye.

 

[tedy2004]

@Darkwolfix I may have sounded mean in my arguments about you and the other guy, but I was just showing my opinion in the arguments like you did too and I was not angry at you, I was baffled at @Kamikira00's arguments that related to his opinion with human's biology but that's his opinion, that is all.

 

[Darkwolfix]

@tedy2004 it is never wrong to use an opinion to express the topic you want to talk and your perspective. The problem starts when people use it as facts or as a foundation for a hypothesis/assumption to what the following debate will develop from. I can't say nor elaborate more with respect to the other reader's post since I didn't read it.

This is the reason why people never mix religion with any other type of topics, especially emotions. People become very passionate.

Now, this is my opinion. As a "catholic" [ since that is how my family baptized me as but I would say I am more of a more open-minded person to any type of probabilities that has some sort of plausible -logic-], religion should not be used for serious topic that develop in too much depth. In fact, I think religions in general should only be used as a elementary education and teach people moral values and the principals of what Society consider what is right and/or wrong.

I say society instead of -god(s)- because we have so many current found ancient journals that are not exposed but were excluded by/and in many /sacred/ messages and leaders. If we pay attention to history and new discoveries, we can see how many religions and current religions that started as cults [ mentioned this because nowadays we kind of give a bad stigma to cults for many reasons] have their origins very influenced by the many interpretations and misunderstanding of interpretations of previous religions and, in some occasions, history from old civilizations.

with that said, I respect your opinion. If you focus in religion and that is why you mention the word sin and how you judge things that's fine. I will just restrain from making other attempts because religion shouldn't be introduced nor used to judge things. It is not what I consider we should focus on to elaborate in a debate. At least, you want to debate religion itself as the topic and is not the case in here.

 

[tedy2004]

@Darkwolfix, I truly agree with your opinion however I still related my religion to my opinion against the other guy since he related his opinion to human biology and I felt that I had too, was nice talking.

 

[Xhurxhx]

Now this is quite the roller coaster.

Spoiler

first half is cute then they add that tad of spice with ami finding out. 3/4 chapters in and all i can think of is, "WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO SPICE"

9/10 only read if you want a loli version of domestic girlfriend.

 

[kobi]

Wincest

 

[wzmbzs07]

idk why I'm like this, I'm okay with this types of genres. like, I'm totally fine with incest IF IT'S FICTIONAL. but irl, i bet i would have the most disgusted face ever to be seen...

 

[Dark_Tifanny69]

That ending was satisfactory. I am now able to sleep soundly tonight.
I also still need to read the oneshot after story and I hope the author has some more good manga.

10/10 would recommend
You'll enjoy reading this, especially if you do it in one go. The rollercoaster of emotions, the way that you could laugh in the most misplaced moments, how the art in some pages are absolutely beautiful. And last but not least, the whole story of their romance and how they overcame the hardships and tough situations together. It was all amazing, and this is the first time I gave a manga and actual reveiw like this but I'm glad it's my first cause this manga deserves it tenfold.

 

[NeroPR]

It ended in a much better note than most "incest" works tend to end. I just was caught by surprise with the parents getting them going down there scene, it legitimate gave that chill through the spine and I thought "Oh Fuck!" to myself. Legit thought we could have had a very dark end if things played out differently at the end, but much respect for the author keeping it fluffy and positive throughout the course of the whole series, minus the Meiko scene that everyone hated. All things considered, this author earns my respect in not using the not blood related trope as a safe card, hell, or even the Oreimo route of the siblings going through the "just this one time, then back to being just siblings" phase, providing the readers with a bittersweet end.

I gave it a 7/10, I'm not into the taboo themes most of the time but the author made it enjoyable enough for me to bare with they being normal siblings and it knew what the manga wanted to be, no bullshit, no beating around the bush, the MC never went back after realising his feelings for his sister, and surprisingly enough the sister was the one who was always into him to begin with, being the reason why she went to an only girls school, which I find it dumb because cut short all possibilities of interacting with other boys of her age, and possibly falling in love with someone who wasn't her brother. I said once and I'll say it again, mad respect for the author getting to publish these, especially with some juicy scenes like the one where shit hit the fan.

 

[Ironi]

4th time reread

 

[Arin-san]

I see some very positive comments, looks like I finally have something good to read.

 

[lavanek0]

After reading this, I have the very strong feeling to alt f4 myself. good manga to want to alt f4 yourself, 10/10

 

[greatninja3]

a rare incest is wincest cause other incest is ether incest losing cause muh Japanese publisher stopping the incest cause it won't sell or Japanese government will hate us or it's ugh fake incest DISGUSTING

 

[Lexonidas]

Good story.
Incest isn't illegal and we live in a free world so u can do whatever u want when u become an adult. U can be in a relationship with ur sibling but u need to be aware that u shouldn't have kids because there is very high chance of genetic mutations (that is at least what they teach in my country schools) That's it.

Oh and religion got no voice in education. There is a religion class in school but its not mandatory and u can join it if BOTH parent and kid wants it.
also the child can leave it whenever it wants to. no need for parent approval.

 

[Cythical]

pretty good

 

[Nonname123]

Highest key of incest, what can i say?
At least it's well done
7/10

 

[NitemarePack]

Alabama, the manga! 6/10 story kinda wack but good execution

 

[KipTheGamer]

no. just no.

its the only thing I have seen that actually tries to pull off incest in a more realistic way, and.... it made me completely disgusted.

I was contemplating why I was usually fine with sister yuri, but not this, brushing it off as I was too far gone down the yuri hole, but I don't think that is the case any more. I feel disgusted, because this isn't a comedy, it is trying to be a real incest romance, and that.... just makes me wince.