I think some people are misunderstanding the context of this world
This world basically has turned adventure quests into Twitch streaming prioritizing entertainment over strength. Even when people know that the the black mage debuffs would be stronger, they would prefer to watch a white mage buff their teammates. Because seeing a team fight faster/stronger/etc. is way more cool than seeing enemies just become slow/blind/etc. while the team kills them easily.
It's not about strength here, but style and popularity.