Rating a comment. :rejected:

[sterven]

@konzolmester
Unsurprisingly you're the only one that needs an explanation but seeing as you "believe" in me here's a list of all the things wrong with you.

Spoiler

 

[Richman]

I just think any kind of comment rating system is pointless/useless, what i would like is better sorting so that we don't have to dig through pages to find the og comment someone is responding to, but that is already planned.

 

[justforthelulz]

@Richman

I just think any kind of comment rating system is pointless/useless

Actually, the comment rating system would be the exact opposite of "point"-less.

 

[Richman]

@justforthelulz
Attention, joke explanation ahead, if you do not like jokes being explained, do not reveal, thanks.

Spoiler

The rating system would use points, but the purpouse of the rating system itself is what i find pointless.

 

[justforthelulz]

@Richman
Did you really have to go and explain the joke for the benefit of the handful of people whose heads it flew over?

 

[Richman]

@justforthelulz
You can't trust humans! But i'll put a spoiler warning just for you.

 

[konzolmester]

@sterven
Hey I'm not demanding it, no pressure here. I just asked an easy simple sincere question.
You wrote and targeted that towards me on my thread in the first place. If you feel personaly offended you have a right to, cause its the truth.
But you put up a guy in question (me), and I'm asking for the reason behind it.
If you observe, so far you and a handfull of trolls rejecting this implementation are doing nothing but shitposting, insulting and theme twisting like that guy with the covid face mask and what not LOL...
So.... as I said, take your time and reply in an orderly fashion with at least some argument.

 

[Richman]

IF: The comment rating system is for discussion, i don't think it's that useful, because people will end up siding with the majority most of the time, i would prefer just having a discussion with arguments and puting an end with it through words, not by who has the most points.

IF: The comment rating system is for showing appreciation, i think it should only go up, no downvote option, you don't like a comment, you ignore it and move on.

 

[Halo]

Just a small reminder for you, a few weeks ago where you dumped your usual garbage shitposting on my suggestion, it has gotten the green planned. (manga rate removal / change)

They fixed it

 

[kuro0102]

I will never ever open the comment sections again if any kind of comment rating system gets implemented here. Damn, just reading this suggestion puts me in a bad mood.

 

[konzolmester]

@Richman

end with it through words, not by who has the most points.

Indeed that would be the case on forums and comment sections where grown people are discussing.
But given that MD is used by mostly teen's we need a system that reduces the chaos and helps the people in searching for a proper helpful opinion.

 

[sterven]

@konzolmester
offended? What is there for me to get offended of? You simply showed your true colors I noticed and called you out for it there's nothing for me to be offended by.
If you can't see that then that's on you buddy. Also you say you aren't demanding an explanation but sure as shit won't let it go, I thought that after a few of my replies
you'd understand that I have no intention of explaining myself anymore nor is it my obligation to do so and now before he who must not be named shows up im leaving duces.

 

[Degernase]

@konzolmester

I hope MD won't decide on popularity, because if judged by the other suggestions and comments I've seen, too many half witted people are active

-OP

btw we should implement this voting system that shows the popularity of individual posts

-Also OP

 

[konzolmester]

@Halo Yeah cause one mod gave it the planned green after I had a discussion with a forum moderator they put it into rejected. Just to proove me wrong I guess.
Seeing theres even a conflict among the mod's I fail to see any reason for the suggestion thread to begin with. Guess all the shitposting needs space..

 

[Richman]

But given that MD is used by mostly teen's

?

 

[BraveDude8]

@konzolmester The post was mistakenly tagged. If it had been approved, there would have been a staff response.

We're never removing manga ratings from the site.

EDIT: Also, the majority of our userbase is >23 years old.

 

[Richman]

@BraveDude8
_{Mr bravedude, sorry to correct you but this thread is about comment ratings, not title ratings.}

Edit: Oh wait, i didn't read again! Sorry to ping you at all.

 

[BraveDude8]

@Richman The other thread he's talking about in his last few posts is one he started three weeks ago about manga ratings.

And on the subject of comment ratings, not happening either. Forum style reactions like likes/thumbs up, etc, are being planned, but nothing like what's proposed here. No "reliability ratings", no reduced comment visibility, we're not Reddit.

 

[Teasday]

In case you're curious why the previous one was mistakenly tagged as planned, Plyk didn't read the suggestion properly and thought it was about removing one's own rating because you can't currently do it, you can only change it to something else.

yeah i'm throwing you under the bus

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

And on the subject of comment ratings, not happening either. Forum style reactions like likes/thumbs up, etc, are being planned, but nothing like what's proposed here. No "reliability ratings", no reduced comment visibility, we're not Reddit.

I agree with all of these stances, although I am still a bit hesitant on the forum style reactions . However, if they work similarly to discord reactions, I suppose I would not mind the addition.

@sterven

Unsurprisingly you're the only one that needs an explanation but seeing as you "believe" in me here's a list of all the things wrong with you.

You caught me in the crossfires with this one. I'll overlook it just this once, however, as this thread was a gem to read.

@ Teasday